Header Form

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Are Box Gutters Still on Trend? (& 3 Things To Know In 2024)

Posted on December 11, 2023

Estimated Reading Time : 7 Min.

Share Now :

box gutter

People used to really like box gutters for their home’s drainage system. But now, not many do. Why? Let’s delve in to figure out why box gutters aren’t as popular and look at other options that more people are starting to prefer.

What Are Box Gutters?

Box style gutters are a type of drainage system that can be found on either residential or commercial properties. They’re called “box gutters” because they’re shaped like rectangles and are custom built to fit right under the eaves of a building. They’re usually made of wood and are lined with metal, like aluminum or steel, and their job is to collect rainwater and channel it away from the building. 

But here’s the thing – they need a lot of care to prevent clogs and overflow. If they do, it could cause water damage to both your roof and the inside of your home. Also, they have to be properly installed to be able to manage large volumes of water during severe storms.

3 Things To Know About Box Gutters In 2024

Let’s dig in to understand these three essential things about box gutters that you should be aware of in 2024.

#1. Why Less People Prefer Box Gutters 

People don’t really go for box gutters these days because there are many issues associated with them, including: 

1. Looks Might Not Match: 

Box style gutters are crafted to fit in with traditional or historic homes. This style might not go well with the more modern look that many homes have today.

2. Needs More Care: 

Due to their square shape, box gutters are more prone to clogs compared to other types of gutters. The sharp corners tend to trap debris, potentially leading to blockages if not properly maintained. 

3. Pricey Pick: 

Modern box gutters can be quite expensive because they are built into the structure of the home. This factor makes people lean towards more affordable gutter options that are easier to install and maintain.

4. Risk of Water Damage: 

If box gutters aren’t properly designed or taken care of, they can cause water-related problems. They might overflow and cause leaks, putting your place at risk for water damage. Also, due to their construction and placement, overflowing box gutters can cause structural damage to your home. Because they are situated into the frame of a building, any water damage can impact the foundation of the property, not just the surrounding materials. 

5. Must Comply with Building Codes: 

The construction and materials of box style gutters have to follow building codes and regulations. They need to meet building standards for strong construction and regular maintenance. This aspect has also made people choose other gutter systems for their homes.

6. Tricky to Install: 

Box gutters need to be carefully installed to make sure they work as intended and don’t leak. This complex installation, especially when adding them to existing buildings, makes people prefer simpler gutter systems.

7. Not Many Material Choices: 

Traditional box gutters are mostly made of wood, as they are built directly into the structure of the building. Homeowners and contractors sometimes worry about wood’s durability, upkeep, and resistance to fire. This lack of material choices is one reason why box gutters are becoming less popular.

#2. Better Alternatives For Box Gutters

Here are some better alternatives to box gutters:

Alternatives to box gutters

> K-style Gutters: 

K-style gutters are more common for homes and come in different materials like copper, steel, and aluminum. They’re visible and can be customized to match your home’s style.

> Half-Round Gutters: 

As the name suggests, half-round gutters look like a pipe cut in half. They feature a semi-circle shape and are often seen on historic-style homes. 

> Fascia Gutters:

Similar to box gutters, fascia gutters are seamlessly integrated into the home’s exterior. Attached directly to the fascia, these gutters offer a less obtrusive drainage system. 

Gutter System Accessories:

Along with different gutter styles, you can also upgrade your drainage system with accessories. 

Rain chains

> Rain Chains: 

These offer a unique look and need less upkeep than regular downspouts. They’re often made of copper or other durable materials and guide water from the gutters to the ground.

> Drip Path: 

This trench-like system collects water and prevents pooling around the foundation using permeable materials like gravel or stone. It can work well in places with a lot of rain or high water levels.

> French Drain: 

Similar to a drip path, a French drain is a trench system with permeable materials and also has a perforated pipe. This pipe collects water and directs it away from the home.

> Grading: 

This involves shaping the land around your home to steer water away. It’s a budget friendly and low maintenance choice compared to regular gutters.

While not all gutter styles and accessories fit every home, they give homeowners a range of alternatives to traditional box gutters. It’s crucial to think about your home’s specific needs, like looks, maintenance, and water management, when picking the best alternative.

#3. Which Type of Roof or Home Can Benefit From Box Style Gutters?

Box gutters offer several advantages for specific types of roofs and buildings:

> Flat or Low Slope Roofs: 

Box gutters are great for roofs with a slight slope because they efficiently collect and manage water without needing extra support structures. Placed at the roof’s edge, they gather rainwater, protecting the house’s foundation and preventing water damage to the exterior. For certain roofs, especially flat ones, box gutters offer a functional alternative to typical gutters located at the eaves.

> Historic or Traditional Buildings: 

It is quite common to find box gutters on old houses. Homes from the late 19th to early 20th centuries often feature box style gutters. Their hidden design complements the building’s appearance, allowing architectural details like moldings and cornices to stand out. 

Also read: 4 Surprising Benefits Of Restoring Your Historical Home’s Original Roof

> Large Buildings: 

Box gutters are a practical substitute for other gutter styles, especially in larger buildings or when a custom installation is required. They are designed to hold significant water volumes, which can be directed away using built-in downpipes. Box gutters are suitable for commercial as well as residential buildings with substantial water drainage needs.

Box Gutters vs. Regular Gutters

Although modern box gutters have certain advantages, regular gutters are typically a better option for homes. Here are some reasons why:

> Cost and Maintenance: 

Installing box gutters is more expensive and requires constant care to prevent issues like wood rot and standing water. However, regular gutters, like K-style seamless gutters, are more affordable and require less maintenance, which is why many homes choose them.

> Aesthetics and Suitability: 

While modern box gutters blend in and complement some styles well, they may lack the flexibility and visual appeal of traditional gutters. Regular gutters are available in a variety of materials, colors, and finishes to complement various home styles.

> Gutter Size: 

Because of their size, box gutters might not be appropriate for homes that prefer a more discrete gutter system. On the other hand, regular gutters are more streamlined and often complement the design of houses better.

To sum up, regular gutters are usually a better choice for homes because they go well with a variety of architectural styles, are less expensive, and require less maintenance.

Installation and Maintenance of Box Gutters

Though people don’t choose box gutters as often, they still need to be properly maintained in order to function properly. Here are some tips to keep them in good condition:

> Regular Cleaning: 

Clean the gutters often to prevent blockages and overflow, which can lead to water damage. Remove debris from all corners and flush the gutters to ensure smooth water flow.

> Professional Assistance: 

Get professional help for installation and maintenance to avoid mistakes and ensure correct installation. Professionals can address issues promptly, preventing costly damage.

> Inspection and Repair: 

Regularly inspect the gutters for holes or damage and fix them promptly. Small punctures can be sealed with a compatible sealant available at hardware stores.

> Gutter Guards: 

Install guards or screens to prevent debris from clogging the gutters. These guards allow water to flow while keeping leaves out, reducing the risk of overflow.

Also Read: Expert Tips On Gutter Maintenance For Homeowners

How to Replace Box Gutters

Here’s a simplified step-by-step guide on how to replace box gutters:

1. Take Down the Old Gutters:

> Use a steady ladder, making sure someone helps stabilize it.

> Cut the old gutters at the joints and carefully remove each piece.

2. Get Ready for New Gutters:

> Measure the length you need for the new gutters, considering the eaves and downspouts.

> Cut the new gutters to the right length, leaving a bit extra on each end for joints.

3. Add Gutter Corners:

> Find the corners and hidden joint splices you need.

> Cut the gutter corners at the right angle to fit snugly against the house.

4. Put in Gutter Sections:

> Start with the first gutter section, making sure it’s aligned and secured with brackets.

> Keep adding the other sections, ensuring they’re aligned and connected.

5. Attach the Downspouts:

> Put the downspouts where you want, like corners or near the eaves.

> Cut them to the right length and secure them with brackets.

6. Seal and Check:

> Use sealant on joints and connections to avoid leaks.

> Test the gutters by running water through to make sure they work well.

> Work carefully and double check your measurements to ensure the project goes smoothly.


Although box gutters were a trend in the past, in 2024 they might not suit everyone’s preferences. Some people may opt for alternative gutter systems, like the ones mentioned above, because of their unique styles and ease of installation. 

That is why it’s crucial to carefully weigh the pros and cons of box style gutters and choose a company like BRH Enterprises to install and repair your drainage system. Proper installation, as well as regular maintenance, are also key to ensuring that box gutters function effectively and have a long lifespan.

Choose BRH Enterprises For All Your Gutter Needs

Looking for experts to handle your gutters in Mayville, WI? BRH Enterprises is your go-to local team! We fix, replace, and install box gutters on any style home or business. Our friendly crew ensures a smooth project from start to finish because we are licensed, insured, and dedicated to providing the best gutter protection at affordable prices.

For dependable and stylish gutter upgrades, rely on BRH Enterprises. Give us a call to improve the durability and beauty of your home. Don’t wait – contact BRH Enterprises today at (920) 249-4228 for all your gutter needs and protect your property from water damage!

BRH Enterprises
Skip to content