Brick vs. Vinyl Siding: A Comprehensive Guide

We all know how important it is to choose the right siding for your property. However, homeowners are often unsure which siding type is best for their house. Many homeowners wonder which is the better option: brick vs. vinyl siding. 

Today, in this article, we will compare both of these siding options so you can make an informed decision.

At BRH Enterprises LLC, we are your local siding and roofing company, and we are committed to providing professional siding services in Mayville and the surrounding areas of Wisconsin. 

For a no-obligation discussion with our professionals, give us a call today at (920) 249-4228.

*Please note: Price ranges listed in this article may not reflect the final cost of your project. Prices are subject to change based on various factors such as local labor rates, material quality, and more. All costs established in this article are rough estimates based on average industry rates. 

What is Brick Siding?

Getting started, brick siding is a classic and durable exterior option that involves laying individual bricks in mortar to create a solid, protective barrier for your home. 

Brick siding has been a trusted choice for centuries, with some installations lasting well over 100 years with minimal maintenance. Brick siding is made from natural clay materials, and it provides great durability against moderate weather conditions. 

It also provides good resistance against fire and outstanding insulation properties that can help regulate your home’s temperature throughout the year.

What is Vinyl Siding?

Next, another popular siding option, vinyl is an affordable choice that performs well and looks nice. Vinyl siding is made from durable polyvinyl chloride (PVC), a lightweight siding material that comes in many styles and colors to suit any architectural design. 

The popularity of vinyl siding has grown with time because of its cost-effectiveness and low maintenance requirements. This makes it an attractive option for homeowners who want to add value to their homes without spending a lot.

Also Read: Best Vinyl Siding Brands Of 2024

Brick vs. Vinyl Siding: A Detailed Comparison

Now that you have a basic idea of these options, here we will compare brick and vinyl siding based on some things you should keep in mind when choosing the right material for your home.

#1 Durability: Brick Wins

Brick siding provides great durability and it can last for over 100 years when you maintain it properly. It stands strong against severe weather conditions, doesn’t rot or warp, and provides good resistance to fire, pests, and impact damage. 

On the other hand, vinyl siding is also durable but generally only lasts 20 to 40 years. Also, vinyl siding can be susceptible to cracking in extreme temperatures and may get damaged from strong impacts. 

#2 Cost-Effectiveness: Vinyl Wins

When we compare brick vs. vinyl siding in terms of cost, vinyl is a clear winner. Vinyl siding generally costs anywhere between $3 and $12 per square foot installed.

While brick siding does provide more long-term value, it comes with a higher upfront cost of $4 to $22 per square foot installed. However, it’s important to consider the long-term value – the brick’s longevity might offset its higher initial cost over time.

#3 Property Value: Brick Wins

Homes with brick siding typically maintain higher resale values and are often more attractive to potential buyers. The beautiful appearance and known durability of brick make it a valuable selling point. 

While vinyl siding can also positively impact home value, especially when well-maintained, it generally doesn’t add as much value as brick.

#4 Installation Process: Vinyl Wins

Vinyl siding installation is generally quicker and less labor-intensive than brick installation. Professional installers can easily complete your vinyl siding project in just a few days.

Installing brick siding requires specialized masonry skills and can take significantly longer. This difference in installation complexity mostly affects the overall project timeline and cost.

#5 Design Options: Vinyl Wins

Vinyl siding provides an impressive variety of colors, textures, and styles, including some options that can mimic other materials like wood or stone. 

You can find vinyl siding that looks like brick, giving a similar aesthetics to your property without any higher cost. 

Bricks are often popular for their retro and vintage appearance. It’s harder to find variations in the design, color, and style.

#6 Maintenance Requirements: Tie

Both materials provide relatively low-maintenance solutions. 

Vinyl siding needs occasional cleaning with a garden hose to remove dirt and debris, while brick might need periodic inspection for mortar integrity and occasional repointing. 

Neither option needs frequent painting or extensive upkeep, making them both great choices for busy homeowners.

Also Read: Can You Paint Vinyl Siding?

#7 Weather Resistance: Brick Wins

Brick siding provides superior protection against extreme weather conditions, including high winds, heavy rain, and hail. It’s naturally resistant to moisture and doesn’t expand or contract significantly with temperature changes. 

While quality vinyl siding can handle most weather conditions well, it’s more susceptible to damage from extreme temperatures and severe storms.

#8 Energy Efficiency: Brick Wins

Brick siding has great energy efficiency because of its natural thermal mass properties. It also helps regulate indoor temperatures by absorbing heat during the day and releasing it slowly at night, potentially reducing your energy bills. 

While insulated vinyl siding can provide good thermal protection, it doesn’t match brick’s natural temperature-regulating capabilities.

#9 Environmental Impact: Brick Wins

Brick is an environmentally friendly choice, and it’s made from natural materials. Also, brick siding can be recycled fully at the end of its life. Its long lifespan means less frequent replacement and less waste. 

Vinyl siding, being a plastic-based product, has a larger environmental footprint and isn’t biodegradable or easily recyclable.

How To Choose The Right Siding Material For Your Home

Before choosing between brick vs. vinyl siding, you need to consider some important things.

The first thing to consider when making a decision between brick and vinyl siding is your budget. Brick siding prices are initially higher than vinyl siding, so if cost is a concern, then you can go for vinyl siding. 

Weather conditions in your area matter, too, as brick siding performs differently than vinyl in various climates. 

Consider your home’s architectural style, as some designs work better with brick while others suit vinyl siding perfectly. 

Also, your maintenance preferences, energy efficiency needs, and future plans for the property are equally important to consider. If you plan to sell your home later, remember that brick-siding houses often maintain higher resale values. 

Both materials have their advantages, and your choice should align with your needs, budget, and long-term plans for your home.

Why Should You Consider Combining Brick and Vinyl?

Combining brick and vinyl siding provides practical benefits for many homeowners. A popular approach is using brick siding for the front facade or lower level of your home while installing vinyl siding on the upper levels or back walls. 

This strategic combination can lower overall costs while maintaining a beautiful exterior.

The brick sections provide superior durability in high-traffic areas and create an elegant look, while the vinyl areas keep installation costs manageable. 

Many homeowners appreciate this approach because it allows them to have the classic appeal of brick where it matters most while using affordable vinyl siding in less visible areas.

Whether you choose vinyl or brick siding, it’s important to work with professionals for the installation. For homeowners in Mayville, WI, our team is here to help. 

Also Read: Can I Install New Siding Over Old Siding?

Get Professional Siding Installation In Wisconsin

At BRH Enterprises LLC, we provide high-quality siding installations in Mayville, WI. We are here to assist you in choosing the right material that aligns with your budget, local weather, and design preferences. 

We want to be the only name that comes to your mind for your siding and roofing needs. To learn more about our services, reach out today at (920) 249-4228.